// I need to

ModernizeUpgrade without breaking it RescueFix what someone else started Build NewTurn an idea into a product Reach More PeopleGet found, get used, include everyone

// Company

Case StudiesExpertiseAbout + CareersResourcesContact Book a call →
≡articleBuild New

Learnable Programming

Bret Victor's essay Learnable Programming responds to Khan Academy's live-coding tutorials, and asks how people really learn to program.

Art+Logic Sep 27, 20121 min read

From the Art+Logic archive · written in 2012. The tools may have moved on; the thinking still holds.

More on a recurring theme, Bret Victor has just posted “an immune response” to the Khan Academy’s recent additions covering Computer Science and programming:

Here’s a trick question: How do we get people to understand programming?

Khan Academy recently launched an online environment for learning to program. It offers a set of tutorials based on the JavaScript and Processing languages, and features a “live coding” environment, where the program’s output updates as the programmer types.

Because my work was cited as an inspiration for the Khan system, I felt I should respond with two thoughts about learning:

  • Programming is a way of thinking, not a rote skill. Learning about “for” loops is not learning to program, any more than learning about pencils is learning to draw.
  • People understand what they can see. If a programmer cannot see what a program is doing, she can’t understand it.

Thus, the goals of a programming system should be:

  • to support and encourage powerful ways of thinking
  • to enable programmers to see and understand the execution of their programs

A live-coding Processing environment addresses neither of these goals. JavaScript and Processing are poorly-designed languages that support weak ways of thinking, and ignore decades of learning about learning. And live coding, as a standalone feature, is worthless.

Alan Perlis wrote, “To understand a program, you must become both the machine and the program.” This view is a mistake, and it is this widespread and virulent mistake that keeps programming a difficult and obscure art. A person is not a machine, and should not be forced to think like one.

How do we get people to understand programming?

I have nothing to add other than to tell you to go read the whole thing.

Previous/related posts:

keep going

More to explore in Build New.

All Build New resources →
let's talk

Got a problem like this one?

Tell us what's stuck. A real person replies within one business day.

Talk to our team →

Talk to people who know software, not a sales script.

Your first call is with Aja, our VP of Sales. He'll help make sure you're solving the right problem. Here's what you'll cover together:

  1. What you're trying to accomplish

    The business goal first, then the technology.

  2. Possible approaches

    And the tradeoffs of each, in plain language.

  3. Risks you may not have considered

    Technical and business, before they cost you.

  4. Whether AI changes the math

    What's practical, and what's just hype for your project.

  5. Sensible next steps

    Even if the right next step is not us.

book-a-call.ics

Loading the scheduler…

Open the booking page →

Some problems are easier to explain in writing. Send us a few lines about what you're working on, and we'll reply within one business day. Helpful to include:

  1. What the software does, or should do
  2. What's stuck, or what's worrying you
  3. Any deadline or budget you have in mind
note.md

Loading the form…